Social media use might be dangerous. The consequences are troubling and well-documented, from tragic tales of adolescent life misplaced to educational analysis on the psychological hurt such platforms could cause, together with nervousness, despair, and low shallowness.
But with 59% of the entire world utilizing social media, for a median of two and a half hours per day, based on a 2022 Broadband search, it has additionally turn out to be inextricable from the every day lives and livelihoods of many. It’s not adequate to say social media is unhealthy, don’t use it. We want a extra proactive method. The query typically lacking from the dialogue is: How can social media use be optimized to reinforce our well-being and flourishing?
What’s social media for?
To start, let’s make clear what social media is, and what it’s not. In a 2010 paper, European researchers Andreas Kaplan and Michael Haenlein outline social media as “a bunch of Web-based functions that . . . enable the creation and change of user-generated content material,” in digital communities. Social media contains platforms equivalent to Fb, LinkedIn, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, Snapchat, and Pinterest. Pure messaging providers equivalent to WhatsApp don’t meet these standards and will not be thought-about to be social media. It’s this within-platform content-creation performance that makes social media a novel, and nonetheless comparatively novel, type of human interplay.
X
Social media platforms have been designed with earnings in thoughts, fairly than customers’ well-being. To optimize our use of social media, we have to perceive the numerous psychological and well-being components at play on-line. Solely then can we retain well-being and flourish, no matter whether or not social media has been designed to prioritize it.
Nevertheless, typical social media recommendation doesn’t take a structured psychology-based method to well-being. Within the largest systematic review of constructive social media utilization outcomes to this point, I trawled with colleagues by means of the analysis to see how social media use interacts with well-being. The upshot? It is doable to create a constructive spiral in social media utilization, the place utilization helps flourishing; however this requires intentionality and can’t be communicated in a number of fast ideas. It’s because social media impacts us all in another way, relying on age, gender, character, and plenty of different components.
I’d like to supply a roadmap for taking a proactive and tailor-made method to social media engagement and well-being. We carried out our analysis throughout age brackets, nations, and different demographics, utilizing a constructive psychology lens. Whether or not you might be an grownup wishing to make use of social media as a part of your profession growth, or an adolescent for whom social media is tough to choose out of, the goal of the suggestions beneath is to empower you in your social media use right this moment, fairly than await gradual or unsure coverage change.
What does flourishing appear to be?
What does it appear to be to flourish on-line? Our analysis, drawing on established constructive psychology flourishing frameworks, breaks it down into two broad domains.
- Social capital and social help. Is social media serving to to help you if you’re burdened? Are you constructing reciprocal relationships with different people by means of your social networks, although each weak and powerful ties? In the event you really feel just like the solutions to these questions are sure, you’re heading in the right direction towards flourishing on-line. Research have discovered that that is utterly doable: For instance, German Neubaum and his colleagues present in a 2014 paper that social media produces short-term constructive feelings and presents social help by means of speedy emotional reduction after crises. Two bigger systematic opinions, one focused on breast cancer patients and one other examining general social support, discovered that social media can certainly present actual consolation and friendship.
- Identification. Identification is a broad idea encompassing multidimensional elements that create one’s sense of self. In a 2020 study, Rebecca Pera and her colleagues discover the “digital self” to be an more and more essential element of subjective well-being. That’s no shock: The flexibility to generate multi-media content material on social media, which Oxford College’s Bernie Hogan conceptualizes as a web-based “exhibition,” additionally opens up opportunities for self-presentation, self-expression, and id growth. When Judith Kasperiuniene and Vilma Zydziunaite systematically reviewed 17 research of how skilled id is constructed by means of social media in a 2019 paper, they discovered a “spiral of transformation” as individuals proactively designed and formed skilled identities on-line—after which obtained suggestions and help on these. This will allow profession transition, carving our skilled niches and related networks, and kind a key a part of our skilled growth.
- Mastery. It’s additionally price mentioning the idea of “mastery,” which is core to numerous well-being frameworks. Mastery can comprise numerous subdomains—expertise acquisition, studying, accomplishment, self-efficacy, and self-worth. This will occur in college settings, the place social media offers peer help teams and studying environments, and organizations, the place it could promote information change and well-being. Of their systematic review of social media use in medical schooling, Christine Cheston and her colleagues discovered learner engagement and energetic studying to be essential advantages from social media-enabled interplay and learner-generated content material.
5 methods to get these outcomes
What situations will enhance the probability of social help, wholesome id formation, and mastery? The analysis exhibits that situations and outcomes are inextricably linked: The flourishing outcomes affect these identical situations, creating potential for a constructive spiral. Our analysis has recognized 5 key situations as pivotal for attaining the flourishing outcomes.
1. Handle social comparability. By far the most important determinant of on-line well-being is the extent to which social comparability happens for the person.
Social comparison is the method of enthusiastic about different individuals in relationship to the self. That is amplified on social media because of the speedy, fixed provision of details about others. Whereas, typically, the findings counsel that extra social comparability is worse for well-being, we discover, upon nearer inspection, that it may be efficiently managed.
For instance, the analysis highlights that various kinds of social comparability produce totally different well-being results. There’s a distinction between evaluating one’s opinions in opposition to others (opinion-based comparability) versus evaluating one’s skills. Opinion-based comparability by way of social media can, in reality, enhance well-being and emotions of optimism and inspiration, as Solar Younger Park and Younger Min Baek present in a 2018 study. Due to this fact, fairly than merely saying, social comparability is unhealthy, don’t evaluate, one may discover, and give attention to, explicit kinds of comparability.
Comparability will also be a constructive stimulus: Some research means that the concern of lacking out (FOMO) social comparability can truly encourage social connection. Likewise, benign envy—the place the intention is to not harm the place of the superior different—is usually a supply of inspiration. Consequently, people may deliberately channel such comparability towards inspiring constructive change.
Totally different individuals have totally different social comparability orientations—that’s, they’re vulnerable to totally different quantities of comparability based mostly on particular person variations and circumstances. Being extra intrinsically motivated, and clear on one’s personal objectives, can assist cut back the affect of social comparability. Higher offline well-being additionally reduces comparability, as does decreasing the time spent on-line.
Lastly, proactive administration of social comparability may be so simple as selecting websites that are much less conducive to social comparability, such as Twitter, and being aware when utilizing platforms worst for comparability (e.g., LinkedIn).
2. Perceive how social media impacts our basic psychological wants. Self-determination principle identifies three psychological wants underpinning human motivation:
- Autonomy: a sense of management with the absence of exterior pressures;
- Relatedness: connectedness with others; and
- Competence: the flexibility to behave successfully and meaningfully.
Relatedness is usually positively associated with well-being from social media utilization. Social media will also be used to compensate for low ranges of relatedness or competence. For instance, Fb was found to support those that lacked the social expertise required to develop social capital and confidence by means of standard routes.
However whereas it’d assist us join with others, social media concurrently impinges our autonomy by means of its addictive design. That is highlighted by the combined outcomes ensuing from abstinence or discount of social media consumption. There are diminishing returns from time spent on social media: In a 2019 study, Zahir Vally and Carline D’Souza discover that full abstinence reduces well-being by severing social channels and growing loneliness.
In the meantime, Melissa G. Hunt and her colleagues, in addition to Julia Brailovskaia and her colleagues, discovered that limiting social media utilization improved future utilization behaviors, bettering autonomy and well-being considerably. Thus we suggest utilizing social media deliberately for connection, however experimenting with ranges of utilization and intervals of abstinence to manage the strain between connection and autonomy.
In actuality, limiting social media use might be arduous! Mindfulness, that’s, the self-regulation of consideration on to the speedy expertise, presents a key right here. For these with better ranges of mindfulness, social media use can decrease burnout at work and enhance their sense of self-esteem and clarity about their id. Over time, by constructing self-regulation and autonomy assets, we will get higher at limiting our time on-line (and restrict senseless scrolling), and due to this fact get the advantages of connection with out the lack of private autonomy.
3. Tailor social media approaches to particular person variations, wants, and motivations. Particular person variations are key in figuring out how people might be affected by social media.
Quite than binary outcomes suggesting social media is both good or unhealthy for introverts or extraverts, findings are extra nuanced, suggesting that social media can profit each extraverts or introverts in several methods, and that character impacts utilization differentially.
For instance, high-functioning introverts are higher at being really alone with out resorting to social media, however on the identical time, these with low social competence (or the socially anxious) might benefit from the connection alternatives afforded by social media. What does appear clear, although, is that folks larger in neuroticism present extra depressive symptoms on-line.
Different notable particular person variations embody age and gender. Older teams have a extra intimate expertise with social media and are much less vulnerable to detrimental comparability and nervousness. Males are discovered to expertise better well-being advantages from social media. Why? In accordance with one study, girls are extra probably than males to hyperlink social comparability and physique dissatisfaction. All which means that to be intentional on-line means taking individualized approaches based mostly on demographics, traits, and preferences.
4. Acknowledge the affect of particular social media platforms and their traits. Social media platform design has created totally different environments, by means of what has been described as “selection structure” designed to affect our habits, as Amy Binns describes in a 2014 paper. Every platform has totally different options which can be conducive to totally different ranges of comparability and connection, whereas influencing person habits, confidence, and experiences. As briefly touched upon above, LinkedIn was found to induce essentially the most social comparability, and Twitter the least.
Totally different options produce totally different well-being results. Analysis suggests loneliness decreases and happiness will increase on account of image-based social media use, whereas text-based Twitter is impartial. Other results counsel this can be a results of the intimacy provided by image-based social media. Instagram’s pretty latest possibility for customers to cover their “like” counts from others is a constructive and important step towards decreasing “likes-based” comparability. Total, take note of how totally different social media platforms make you’re feeling, with the attention that these emotions will not be your “fault,” however fairly a operate of their design. Contemplate which options may contribute to this in your explicit case, and alter your utilization accordingly.
5. Work on offline well-being to help constructive outcomes. A lot of the analysis highlights the bidirectional relationship between social media and well-being. That’s, larger ranges of basic well-being translate to a greater social media expertise. This has the advantage of shifting the main focus off social media, to key well-being dimensions, equivalent to bodily well being and offline relationships. The extra we will construct our offline assets, together with sense of id, autonomy, and well-being, the much less probably social media is to intervene with our well-being and the extra likelihood we will profit from its flourishing alternatives.
This text just isn’t about whether or not social media is nice or unhealthy. Certainly, at any given time limit, we could “like” or dislike social media. No matter this choice or opinion, social media is more and more embedded into the best way enterprise and social life function right this moment. Due to this fact if we’re to make use of it, let’s concentrate on its distinctive options and the way these work together with our personal psychological wants, particular person traits, and well-being.
