by Miroslav Imbrišević
____
Not too long ago I learn a definition of ‘Terf’: they’re “cis ladies who deny the womanhood of transwomen.” [https://www.zeit.de/zett/queeres-leben/2022-04/phenix-kuehnert-weiblichkeit-trans-frau].
That made me take into consideration the query of group membership. How do you purchase it? Surprisingly, it’s by no means by way of self-ID. Historically there are two routes: [1] through the present members; or [2] particular, related info should get hold of.
If I wish to be part of the illustrious Marylebone Cricket Membership, then solely the present members may also help me: I need to discover two full members who would help my membership, and there mustn’t be any objection to my membership by any of the opposite full members. After I grew to become a British citizen, solely the British state, and by extension the British individuals, might grant me citizenship – no matter whether or not I had self-identified as British for years, nonetheless many Carry-On films I had seen, and whether or not I stood up within the tub (like Jacob Rees-Mogg), each time the nationwide anthem got here on the radio. German or Croatian officers couldn’t grant me British citizenship, solely the Brits might.
The opposite path to membership is through sure related info. If you wish to depend as a girl, you should have a feminine physique (which then might result in a sure socialisation and experiences or not). With out the feminine physique, there is no such thing as a girl. This isn’t organic essentialism, however a matter of definition. Equally, solely those that truly are black (i.e., have black ancestors) depend as black, and solely those that have a recognised incapacity depend as disabled. This isn’t organic essentialism both. Individuals who assume they will self-ID into these classes reside in a special actuality.
If you wish to be a rockstar, you should have completed ‘rockstar issues’ (launched an album; be within the charts, and so forth., see here). If you wish to be a Trekkie, you should costume up just like the actors on Star Trek, and ideally you should have watched most or all episodes of the TV collection, and maybe you converse Klingon. Self-identifying as a Trekkie, with out dressing up and with out having watched any episode of Star Trek, is not going to make you right into a Trekkie. Some “Trekkie-facts” should get hold of.
Some transwomen play the gender function “girl” in a stereotypical method: pearls, frilly blouses, excessive heels, hand baggage, and so forth. Some have gender-affirming surgical procedure (breasts, facial feminisation, and so forth.). Others should not taking part in the half in any respect; they solely depend on self-ID. They’ve male our bodies and seem like males, however declare to be ladies. The latter are like Trekkies who merely self-ID, however who don’t costume up, haven’t seen any episode, and don’t use the phrase “Dwell lengthy and prosper!” The difficulty is, if not one of the minimal Star-Trek-facts (carrying a uniform, familiarity with the TV collection, and so forth.) get hold of, then you aren’t a Trekkie.
So far as I see, self-ID by no means offers group membership. So, would dressing up, and “appearing like a girl” make you right into a member of the group, identical to Trekkies do? At first look it would seem like it, nevertheless it seems that it doesn’t. Once we are coping with a Trekkie, then sure info should get hold of: pretending to be a Starfleet officer, having a uniform, utilizing a hair-dryer as a phaser, and so forth. Right here, appearing (pretending to be one thing you aren’t) the a part of Kirk, Spock or Uhura constitutes being a Trekkie – these are the membership-granting info. Trekkies perceive that you just can’t develop into Spock, you may solely fake to be Spock; and that’s the way you develop into a Trekkie.
These transwomen who play the function of “girl,” have thereby not glad any membership-granting situations, as a result of these differ from those who apply to Trekkies. The membership situation for the category “girl” – the truth that should get hold of – is having a feminine physique, not taking part in a job. The gender-role “girl” is secondary, or parasitic on having a feminine physique. In contrast to with Trekkies, taking part in the gender function of girls isn’t a membership-granting reality; it is just one thing that’s usually related with being a girl. A would-be Trekkie who takes on the function of Captain Kirk thereby turns into a Trekkie; he doesn’t develop into Kirk, and most Trekkies are conscious of this. A transwoman who performs the function of “girl” turns into the equal of a Trekkie: she doesn’t develop into a girl, however solely turns into somebody who aspires to be a girl.
However maybe the primary route is the best way to go? What if there are ladies – trans allies – who recognise transwomen as ladies? May this recognition not grant group membership? As we’ve got seen with membership membership and citizenship, sure conventions or authorized procedures have to be in place. There isn’t any operative conference in place which might bestow membership to the category “girl” when invoked by present members (i.e., ladies). Feminists out and in of academia might intone the mantra “trans ladies are ladies,” nevertheless it has no (authorized) impact.
There may be, in fact, a authorized process in lots of nations now which offers for a change of gender. And this entails that authorized paperwork could also be altered: usually the beginning certificates will now state beneath intercourse: “feminine.” This doesn’t imply that the unique beginning certificates was in error; that individual continues to be biologically male and can very probably want therapy for prostate most cancers in previous age. The state is merely using a authorized fiction, as I’ve defined here. In a slender juridical sense, the state will deal with a transwoman as if she had been a girl. British law-makers had been conscious of this authorized fiction once they debated the Gender Recognition Act in Parliament in 2003 (see here). For that reason, UK laws permits the exclusion of transwomen from sure contexts (e.g., sport, peerages, single-sex provisions, and so forth.). In the event that they actually had been ladies in all respects, these exclusions can be an injustice. So, the state is simply pretending, identical to the Trekkies are pretending. The distinction is that the pretence of the aspiring Trekkie makes them right into a Trekkie, whereas the pretence of the state doesn’t make a transwoman into a girl. It solely grants them sure rights. Within the UK, the state treats them, in some respects, as in the event that they had been ladies, however not in all respects. In laws the place there aren’t any exemptions and no recognition of the underlying authorized fiction, transwomen and girls are legally indistinguishable. And this may result in confusion amongst trans individuals and their allies: they begin to imagine the mantra.
The above definition of ‘Terf’ assumes that membership to the category “girl” goes through the primary route: the present members of the category can bestow membership. However womanhood isn’t a membership one can be part of, if different members conform to it. In reality, membership depends on route [2]: sure info should get hold of, no matter what allies might say.
In fact, some laws (in Eire, for example) already permits self-ID with regards to gender, and the brand new German authorities is getting ready such a legislation. However this is able to create a precedent for group membership, and it’s troublesome to see why, as a consequence, we shouldn’t permit individuals to determine into any variety of different classes. The probabilities are limitless. And this Alice-in-Wonderland situation explains why up till now self-ID was by no means an choice with regards to situations of group membership. However, the occasions, they’re a-changing.
Miroslav Imbrišević teaches philosophy on the Open College/UK
