by Preston Stovall
___
U.S. residents are dealing with a disaster in political polarization and psychological well being immediately. During the last decade, charges of self-harm and melancholy have skyrocketed among young Americans. This affect will not be evenly distributed throughout the inhabitants, nonetheless, as it’s centered on heavy customers of social media (“heavy use” varies from research to review, however it’s usually round 5 or extra hours per day), and the impact seems strongest among young girls. New media applied sciences have opened up our private {and professional} lives to public scrutiny, and the ensuing stress we face to curate a public picture seems to be harming the younger individuals most invested in it.
Turning to the trend in political polarization, the PEW Analysis Heart has been learning political sentiments amongst U.S. residents for the reason that Nineteen Nineties. In regards to the diploma to which Democrats and Republicans maintain not solely unfavorable however very unfavorable views of the opposite aspect, a hanging sample has emerged. Whereas this quantity was solely 15% for every celebration within the Nineteen Nineties, it grew to 40% in 2014. And by 2016, higher than 50% of every political wing regarded the opposite aspect very unfavorably. This rise in political polarization seems to be fueled by the consumption of media – each outdated and new.
Throughout the identical interval that political polarization unfold throughout the US, U.S. residents started overestimating the degree to which the most extreme political views had been held by members of the opposite celebration. On the manufacturing aspect of issues, this result’s largely owed to the event of the 24-hour information cycle within the Nineteen Nineties, with opponents branding themselves alongside celebration strains within the curiosity of securing dwindling market shares throughout longer spans of time. With the rise of latest media platforms within the 2000s and 2010s, and the echo chambers and epistemic bubbles these platforms foster, our political conversations are more and more dominated by voices which have solely probably the most uncharitable issues to say about each other (see additionally C. Thi Nguyen’s discussion of both these phenomena).
On the identical time, this example offers trigger for optimism. Partisans of every aspect are so misinformed in regards to the different solely as a result of it’s the vocal extremists who’re doing a lot of the speaking. And the info suggests {that a} substantial variety of individuals, on either side of the political aisle, agree with each other about more than they realize. On the aspect of media consumption, then, if we may maintain the extremist voices to a minimal (or if we had been higher at tuning them out) we’d uncover we share extra frequent floor with each other. And so what seems as a public well being disaster now appears to confess of a remedy: our state of affairs requires extra considerate manufacturing and consumption of media content material.
Over the previous couple of years, rising consideration has been given to media literacy, which goals to provide younger individuals and adults higher strategies for responsibly consuming information and social media. Organizations that foster media literacy embody the National Association for Media Literacy Education, the Center for News Literacy at Stony Brook College, the curriculum for Civic Online Reasoning at Stanford, the News Literacy Project, and the vital evaluative mission Mapping Impactful Media Literacy Practices. With assist from Humanities Montana, and hosted on the Center for Science, Technology, Ethics, and Society at Montana State College, MSU philosophers Kristen Intemann, Bonnie Sheehey, and I’ve been engaged on a program bringing Critical Thinking about Social Media to excessive faculties in Montana. Our purpose is to sensitize younger individuals to the sorts of manipulation, misinformation, and misanthropy breeding in on-line public areas immediately.
A mission of this kind appears not solely worthwhile, however one thing like a process of the interval through which we reside. Simply because the applied sciences of writing and the printing press opened up new avenues for social, scientific, and materials cultural improvement, so have the general public and semi-public fora of on-line interplay launched a wealth of latest alternatives into human life. As certainly because it was vital for customers to direct these earlier applied sciences towards ends that foster human flourishing, irrespective of how imperfectly pursued, so is it incumbent on us immediately to think twice in regards to the makes use of and abuses of latest media, social and in any other case.
Preston Stovall is an assistant professor in philosophy at the College of Hradec Králové within the Czech Republic. He works within the philosophy of language, the philosophy of thoughts, and metaphysics.
