Epistemic Refusal as a Form of Indigenous* Resistance and Respect

“Refusal is concurrently a negation of entry to data and assets, in addition to an affirmation of sovereignties.” Rachel Flowers

I’m an Indigenous thinker, and my analysis explores the varied sorts of relations between Indigenous folks and those that declare to be their allies. Relations are important to many Indigenous communities. Not solely can we keep relations with different people, however we additionally stand in relations with our nonhuman counterparts, also known as kinfolk. These embody, however will not be restricted to—our bodies of water, land formations, spirits, crops, and naturally, different animals. It’s by our relationships with others that our obligations and duties to 1 one other develop into evident. At its simplest, these relations inform our method of being on the earth. I keep that I additionally stand in a relation with my college students; one thing past simply that as professor. Whereas I’ve a accountability to coach them, to what extent do I’ve that accountability? And the way do I navigate instruction when it entails the traumatic tales and experiences of Indigenous folks, to whom I additionally stand in relation?

As settler colonial nation-states, the histories of america and Canada are replete with examples of war waged in opposition to the Indigenous folks residing inside their colonial borders. Governmental insurance policies—like assimilation, removal, relocation, and termination—along with laws adopted to deal with traditionally unjust practices—such because the sixties scoop, birth alerts, and the repatriation of ancestral stays from museums and universities—converse to the varied methods by which this conflict was waged. But, it could be a mistake to assume that colonialism was an historic occasion that’s largely over, and that there aren’t any battles presently being fought. That is what settler ignorance prompts one to imagine.

Settler ignorance is an “expansion” of Charles Mills’ account of white ignorance. Underneath the affect of white ignorance, people maintain incorrect beliefs in regards to the racialized world by which they stay. They’re unaware of the workings of their society and won’t see the constructions that marginalize and oppress folks of shade. White ignorance endorses a racial superiority that isn’t solely maintained by white folks; it could be internalized by folks of shade as nicely. Though these beneath the sway of white ignorance fail to know the reality in regards to the world, this ignorance comes with social benefits, and it’s these advantages that encourage the preservation of the established order.

White ignorance, nevertheless, lacks the assets to deal with the lived information of Indigenous folks in a colonial society. Admittedly, race, and significantly racism, play a task within the oppression and marginalization of Indigenous folks of Turtle Island. Being Indigenous, nevertheless, is rather more than belonging to a specific racial group. Indigenous folks comprise sovereign nations which have existed since time immemorial, and so they have survived colonial makes an attempt to eradicate them; racism is simply a part of the oppression perpetuated through colonialism.

By insurance policies targeted on assimilation, colonial governments imposed a European (and largely Christian) understanding of gender and its societal roles. Colonialism destroyed the sovereignty of matrilineal societies, regulated the efficiency of gender on reserves, and erased the existence of two spirit people in lots of communities. In the present day, it exists within the failure of america and Canada to investigate instances of lacking and murdered Indigenous girls and women, the lack to coordinate resources that assist within the prevention of these instances, and the unwillingness to search for remains. Colonialism finds expression within the political strikes to take away Indigenous children from their properties and incarcerate Indigenous girls disproportionately. Therefore the oppression of colonialism isn’t strictly racist, it’s heterosexist/cissexist as nicely.

One other avenue of oppression dedicated by colonization is the introduction of the idea of personal property. It started with the taking of land and the breaking of our relationships, which resulted in nice losses of information, language, and tradition. It now seems within the assaults on reserves and reservations dedicated within the title of nationwide safety. Cloaked in phrases like “resource acquisition,” “fossil fuel transports,” and “disposal” of nuclear waste, these assaults happen on Indigenous land throughout america and Canada with little to no session. Additionally they pose a risk to lives and contribute to well being disparities. Commodification isn’t restricted to land; it additionally extends into Indigenous knowledge and culture. (And typically even non-Indigenous arts and/or crafts!) Racism, sexism, and the commodification of Indigenous land and tradition are key options of colonialism. The resurgence of Indigenous folks couldn’t be achieved if our resistance merely addresses racism. Thus, white ignorance fails to totally seize what society doesn’t know in regards to the expertise of being Indigenous and dwelling in a colonial nation-state.

Greater than a spot in information in regards to the Indigenous folks, settler ignorance has the flexibility to oppress Indigenous folks and their communities. Multi-disciplinary scholarship in social epistemology (Nelson & Godlewska, 2023) exposes settler ignorance as “a deliberate social and institutional ideology that defines what can and can’t be recognized, and that manipulates and oppresses specific [Indigenous] our bodies in reinforcing hierarchical energy.” The ideology of dominant society is launched within the formal schooling methods of settler nation-states, the place college students are indoctrinated by a colonial curriculum that usually overlooks and excludes the voices of Indigenous folks. This ideology is reified within the public spheres of discourse, comparable to historic markers, and epistemic niches (to the purpose that folks stay in areas with Indigenous names and but, have no idea that they stay on ancestral land). Notably, settler ignorance camouflages the battles which can be occurring immediately.

Modern acts of aggression in opposition to Indigenous folks dwelling throughout the colonial borders of america and Canada may not appear to be the overt insurance policies legislated by settler governments or the literal battles that had been labelled massacres in america. Nonetheless, among the modern and up to date protests of Indigenous folks in america and Canada have been met with militarized safety and police forces, and people do bear a hanging resemblance to the historic conflict campaigns. Footage within the information starting from Wounded Knee and the Oka crisis to Standing Rock and the Wet’suwet’en Protest attest to the militarized responses dispatched in every case.

Though the militarized responses are excessive and extra seen given the presence of social media, there are different cases of settler ignorance which can be extra delicate and covert. These instances come up from colonialism embedding itself into methods, like healthcare and even into the transfer to decolonize greater schooling. One battle that I, as an Indigenous scholar, encounter professionally is the negotiation of disseminating data whereas on the identical time preserving the fitting to refuse such data within the curiosity of resistance to settler ignorance. Am I furthering the pursuits of settler ignorance if I refuse to make data concerning Indigenous folks or communities accessible to my college students, particularly if there’s a risk that they might be taught from it? Merely put, how ought to I navigate the duties to my college students and to Indigenous folks? To make clear, I’ll current an instance: a standard prevalence taken from programs that I’ve beforehand taught.

Irrespective of the course, whether or not introductory or higher stage, the primary day of instruction usually consists of presenting the syllabus in addition to mentioning the matters that will probably be coated all through the time period. In response, I’ve observed that college students react in a different way relying on whether or not the course is primarily Indigenous philosophy or western philosophy. In my Indigenous programs, I’m invariably requested if data on cultural practices will probably be made accessible and if there will probably be any visitor audio system. Questions concerning the potential of cultural practices are simply handled as the scholars who ask these questions are often not conversant in philosophy. Tradition on this case would solely be addressed insofar because it connects with philosophical thought. After being launched to what philosophy is, they arrive to know why the emphasis isn’t essentially cultural.

The second query concerning visitor audio system isn’t as straightforward for me to deal with. In my western philosophy programs, I’m by no means requested if we may have a visitor speaker. In these lessons, it’s understood that I’m an authority; I’m a thinker. As somebody who presents as white, I fear that in my Indigenous programs I’m not seen as Indigenous and due to this fact not as credible. On condition that this takes place after I’ve launched myself, even utilizing the language of my folks, I’ve been looking for solutions in social epistemology.

One reply I contemplate possible is that settler ignorance calls for tales. In programs taught by non-Indigenous school there’s a development of getting visitor audio system or classes on tradition as a result of most don’t really feel certified to show Indigenous topics. Whereas I believe this follow could produce other points linked with it that I can’t handle right here, what I wish to name consideration to is the expectation of my college students to have an Indigenous individual share their story or tradition with them.

Tales are very highly effective, and in Indigenous contexts, they supply logical house for us to strive on concepts with out committing us to the results of performing on them (Burkhart 2019, xxiii). However I fear that the expectation for tales and visitor audio system is doing one thing else. Whereas educating a course on cultural competency and security given a framework of social justice to future nurses, I current the methods by which colonialism has contributed to the disparities in healthcare between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people. On this course too, I’m requested about risk for visitor audio system and cultural instruction. However the tales within the context of healthcare run the danger of reaffirming unfavorable stereotypes, they’re triggering, and typically painful. Tales that describe particular person experiences at Indigenous residential colleges, with substance use and abuse, regarding lacking and murdered Indigenous girls and women, and of incidents of racism in hospitals that the majority usually lead to neglect and loss of life are solely among the matters we are going to handle all through the time period. Whereas the coed would possibly be taught from private accounts, should these accounts be consumed on this specific option to fulfill the aim of instruction? This query is particularly salient given the presence of Indigenous college students in these programs.

What I believe is at concern is that settler ignorance requires that information should be cloaked or wearing such a method as to fulfill the sensibilities that usually shield the ideology grounding it. There’s a dynamic at play within the requests for trauma-laden tales. It might be implicit within the unwitting demand, however it additionally seems within the dedication of credibility of these telling the tales. Indigenous persons are all too conversant in the calls for for authenticity intertwined with colonial determinations of membership. I discover it illuminating that “folks from minority communities are sometimes compelled to relive agony to get observed and develop into extra seen in each sphere of our lives” (Khan 2022). Within the case of Indigenous folks, tales of trauma assist the settler hierarchy fable (which seems in varied contexts all through Canadian and US historical past and is also known as the “Indian Downside”). These tales additionally protect the consolation of these members belonging to the dominant group. Societal consideration given to Indigenous folks is intertwined with emotions of saviorism. Consideration is deflected to the story or the non-public account; and never on the constructions, methods, or establishments of a colonial society. The demand for tales could result in a passive consumption of information that requires little from the coed, and so they get credit score for his or her attendance. The prevalence of trauma porn isn’t distinctive to Indigenous communities, however it’s a type of epistemic oppression that should be thought-about as establishments of upper studying transfer to indigenize their curriculum and/or decolonize their areas of studying. I envision the correct relation, one that permits me to show college students in a method that resists settler ignorance, will probably be certainly one of respect. A part of what I educate about colonialism is that it’s nonetheless current within the lives of Indigenous folks, and people classes will not be comfy. I think about that some who learn this may occasionally wish to push again. Use of the time period settler ignorance usually receives push again, particularly from those that don’t consider themselves as settlers. Maybe they immigrated, or they’re temporally distanced from the creation of reserves and reservations, however they aren’t comfy with the concept they’re benefiting from the colonization of Indigenous folks. I respect my college students an excessive amount of to permit them to stay comfy and unaware of settler ignorance. To that finish, I refuse some tales—particularly when these come on the expense of Indigenous folks or extra importantly Indigenous college students. And I believe I can do that with out exploiting private trauma and have completed so to an extent within the hyperlinks chosen for this piece. To pursue respectful relations is a technique of answering my query of whether or not I’m foisting some type of epistemic oppression upon my college students, or if I actually have their finest curiosity in thoughts.

* Given the variety of the inhabitants of Turtle Island, it could be an overgeneralization to attribute the views mentioned on this paper as being held by each nation. The views listed here are relevant to these Indigenous communities in North America who share related worldviews and values. There could also be some worldviews shared globally, however I don’t want to converse for my Indigenous colleagues the world over.

The Ladies in Philosophy sequence publishes posts on these excluded within the historical past of philosophy on the idea of gender injustice, problems with gender injustice within the subject of philosophy, and problems with gender injustice within the wider world that philosophy might be helpful in addressing. In case you are curious about writing for the sequence, please contact the Sequence Editor Alida Liberman or the Affiliate Editor Elisabeth Paquette.