History of American Philosophy, Robin M. Muller

The origin story for this course is a bit uncommon. State legislation in California requires college students within the California State College system to have interaction in “complete research” of American historical past and authorities, together with “the historic improvement of American establishments and beliefs.” Programs assembly this requirement are normally structured like surveys in American historical past: Instructors have to show “important occasions” happening throughout the complete geographic vary of the up to date United States over a interval of greater than 100 years, and so they have to explain and analyze the function of various ethnic and social teams in that historical past.

Crafting a philosophy course that met these aims was a problem. Commonplace surveys of American Philosophy that run from, say, Peirce to Rorty, are inclined to current a relatively conventional set of philosophical issues regarding information, that means, fact, expertise, and actuality, that—for all of the emphasis in pragmatism on motion and sensible results—stay indifferent from the panorama of historical past unfolding ‘on the bottom.’ It struck me, nonetheless, that this offered an actual alternative for our division and for our college students: “American Establishments” programs are in extraordinarily excessive demand on our campus (there are just a few accepted choices in a handful of departments), and, with the appropriate strategy, we may acquaint college students with philosophy, not as one thing that occupies some summary realm of concepts—as one thing fully indifferent from materials actuality, in different phrases—however as a self-discipline that’s each immediately attentive to (and shapes) lived realities. (It additionally occurs that, exterior of my skilled life, my mental ardour is nineteen^th-century American historical past, so I knew the course would give me a singular alternative to attach these pursuits within the classroom in methods I’ve been beginning to attempt to join them in my very own work.)

In developing the course, I relied closely on two texts: John Lysaker’s fantastic “Essaying America” and Scott Pratt and Erin McKenna’s assortment American Philosophy from Wounded Knee to the Present. I don’t train immediately from both of these texts, although I do use Pratt’s Native Pragmatism to arrange an vital framework for the course: the excellence between what he calls the “colonial” and the “indigenous perspective.” However the former was actually useful for me as I attempted to work out what turned the general course theme—an try and pose the query, “What is supposed by the ‘American’ in ‘American philosophy’?” The latter textual content, from Pratt and McKenna, was then instrumental in my understanding of the way to join the philosophy to occasions in American historical past. It gave me the thought, for example, for my favourite part of the course—a trio of readings from Frederick Jackson Turner, Simon Pokagon, and Ida B. Wells, that we set towards the background of the 1893 Chicago World’s Truthful. (Turner and Pokagon’s texts have been first offered on the Truthful—Turner’s as a speech and Pokagon’s printed on birch bark—and whereas Wells’ “Lynch Regulation in America” is from 7 years later, she had been a key determine, alongside Frederick Douglass, in up to date critiques of the Truthful, and her speech of 1900 pairs in placing methods with Turner’s “Frontier Thesis” of American historical past).

There was a little bit of tweaking of the course since I first taught it in 2020. However, on the narrative I’ve settled on, the semester begins with an try and problematize the course title, “The Historical past of American Philosophy.” We ask: “What’s American about American philosophy?” “What are we speaking about once we speak about philosophy?” And “What does it imply to ‘do’ the historical past of philosophy?” We then have a look at some celebratory and important conceptions of Americanness to get our important bearings and to apply some methods for the way to learn philosophical texts. From there, the course follows a roughly chronological narrative. We start with a undertaking I name “mythologizing and demythologizing ‘American’,” growing key ideas and instruments to consider the that means and unfolding of American historical past within the work of figures from Cotton Mather to Ida B. Wells. From there, we transfer by way of American transcendentalism and pragmatism as philosophical traditions, taking a look at pragmatism “in motion” (with an emphasis on schooling), earlier than returning to the opening query of the that means of American id. This later part—particularly the studying from Anzalúda, which college students normally single out as a favourite—produces actually wealthy discussions about college students’ personal backgrounds and experiences, and concerning the that means and worth of private narrative within the work of philosophy. Alongside the best way, we have interaction philosophically with each main and minor occasions in American historical past: How did the bloodbath at Wounded Knee influence the type of native resistance to federal energy? What’s the reference in Douglass’ 4^th of July speech to the Fugitive Slave Act, and the way does it assist us perceive his rhetorical technique? What does James’ recounting of the San Francisco earthquake on a go to to California in 1906 inform us concerning the that means of pragmatism? This work usually takes us behind or past the textual content: for example, I discuss concerning the Panic of 1837 and the Broad Avenue Riots in Boston to assist college students think about what the final temper might need been like that August when, in entrance of a room of Harvard college students, Emerson opened his speech “The American Scholar” by celebrating “the survival of letters amongst a folks too busy to offer to letters any extra.” In doing this type of work, my hope for the course is that college students will come to think about historic texts, not simply as artifacts, or as ‘merely’ preserving theories or summary concepts, however as modes of entry to a world—as written by embodied human beings (generally fairly actually by hand), whose pursuits, issues, environments, beliefs, identities, and issues present up within the textual content, if we all know the way to look… that they are going to come to see philosophy as a instrument for understanding these worlds.

The Syllabus Showcase of the APA Weblog is designed to share insights into the syllabi of philosophy educators. We embody syllabi of their authentic, unedited format that showcase all kinds of philosophy lessons. We’d love so that you can be part of this undertaking. Please contact Sequence Editor, Cara S. Greene by way of cara.greene@coloradocollege.edu, or Editor of the Educating Beat, Dr. Smrutipriya Pattnaik by way of smrutipriya23@gmail.com with potential submissions.